Paraskevi: Quality of life outcomes in patients with breast cancer

Quality of life outcomes in patients with breast cancer

Abstract

Health-related quality of life is now considered an important endpoint in cancer clinical trials. It has been shown that assessing quality of life in cancer patients could contribute to improved treatment and could even serve as a prognostic factor along with medical parameters. This paper presents a review of quality of life outcomes in patients with breast cancer according to previous descriptive findings. This is a bibliographic review of the literature covering publications that appeared in English language biomedical journals between 1987 and 2008. The search strategy included a combination of the key words quality of life and breast cancer in the titles of published articles. The major findings are summarized and presented under different headings: evaluation of health-related quality of life i) at the time of diagnosis, ii) during treatment, and iii) after the completion of treatment. Breast cancer patients receiving chemotherapy might experience several side-effects and symptoms that have a negative effect on their quality of life. Also adjuvant hormonal therapies were found to have a similar negative impact on quality of life. Psychological distress-anxiety and depression were found to be common among breast cancer patients. Symptoms-pain, fatigue, and insomnia were among the most common symptoms reported. There was quite an extensive body of literature on quality of life in breast cancer patients. These papers have made a considerable contribution to improving breast cancer care.




Introduction

Breast cancer is the most common cancer among women worldwide. Women are now diagnosed with the disease earlier and live longer. It is, therefore, crucial to consider the individual woman living with breast cancer and its treatment.1 Quality of life has become a well-accepted outcome measure for cancer patients and an integral part of cancer patient management.24 This is partly due to the increasing number of breast cancer patients. Statistics show that each year there is over 1.1 million newly diagnosed women with breast cancer worldwide and 410,000 women die from the disease.5 On the other hand, improvements in early detection and treatment of breast cancer have led to longer survival of these patients. Also, breast cancer affects women's identities and, therefore, studying quality of life in women who lose their breasts is vital. In addition, women play an important role in family. When a woman develops breast cancer, all family members may develop some sort of illness.6

The time of diagnosis, the initial stages of adjuvant treatment and the months immediately following completion of adjuvant treatment are transition times of poor adjustment and decreased quality of life in breast cancer patients.7,8 Studies have shown that decreased health-related quality of life as a result of chemotherapy side-effects may predict early treatment discontinuation in these patients.9 On the other hand, studies on post-treatment adjustment of breast cancer survivors demonstrated that breast cancer patients might benefit from a good quality of life.10 However, according to other findings, the end of treatment can be exceedingly stressful for women with breast cancer, especially for those who have received adjuvant chemotherapy and/or radiation treatments.1115

Over the past ten years, much clinical effort has been directed to the treatment of breast cancer in order to improve survival. Now the question is: to what extent have studies of quality of life in breast cancer patients added to our understanding or contributed to improved outcomes in breast cancer care? This is very difficult to answer, but it is possible to try to investigate the contribution of quality of life studies to breast cancer care as a whole. There are several useful papers on quality of life in breast cancer patients. The aim of the present review is to collect and examine publications that have appeared between 1987 and 2008 in English language biomedical journals. It is hoped that this assessment may contribute to existing knowledge, provide both researchers and clinicians with a better profile on the topic, and consequently help improve quality of life in breast cancer patients.

Materials and Methods

As part of a study on quality of life in breast cancer patients, an extensive literature search was carried out using Medline, Embase, Scopus and PsychInfo database for articles published between 1987 and 2008. We chose 1987 as the earliest year for review to ensure that results would be consistent with current standards of care. To capture literature encompassing a broad set of domains that might be affected by breast cancer or its treatments, we included the following terms in our searches: breast cancer AND quality of life, fatigue, mental health, adjustment, social support, OR function. We use the term quality of life to be synonymous with the expression health-related quality of life. We confined our review to original reports of randomized trials and cohort studies. We excluded methodological articles, reviews, case series, and case reports, and non-English language articles.

Results and Discussion

Quality of life and breast cancer

Breast cancer is the most common malignancy among women worldwide. Approximately 230,480 new cases of invasive breast cancer and 39,520 deaths are expected among US women in 2011.16 Approximately 78% of new cases and 87% of breast cancer deaths in 2011 will occur among women aged 50 years and older. In addition to invasive breast cancers, about 57,650 new diagnoses of in situ breast cancer are expected among US women in 2011.16

Today, quality of life (QoL) surveys are an important issue in health care, especially in oncological research. Cancer affects different aspects of QoL and currently cancer is a major problem all over the world. The time of diagnosis, the initial stages of treatment and the months following completion of treatment are difficult times for patients both physically and emotionally. During these periods, poor adjustment and decreased QoL in breast cancer patients can easily occur.17,18 Therefore, it is critical for health care professionals to become familiar with the impact of a breast cancer diagnosis and its treatment on patients' QoL.19

Quality of life among newly diagnosed patients

Initial diagnosis has been shown to evoke a state of shock, fear and disbelief, thus creating not only a psychological crisis but an existential one as well.20 Most women experience at least some psychosocial distress during the course of their breast cancer diagnosis. The level of distress varies from woman to woman and can vary for the individual patient over the course of diagnosis. Cancer-related distress can be expected to dissipate with time for the majority of women diagnosed with cancer. For others, however, such distress may interfere substantially with comfort, QoL and the ability to make appropriate treatment decisions and adhere to treatment.21,22 Most of the literature on the psychosocial aspects of breast cancer suggest that the vast majority of women adjust well to the diagnosis of breast cancer, and manage the complex and sometimes aggressive treatments associated with primary treatment and recurrent disease.2329 For a minority of women, however, a diagnosis of breast cancer contributes to significant psychosocial distress that can interfere with functioning and QoL.

Quality of life during the treatment

Primary treatment

Once the treatment plan is decided, women with breast cancer may experience some relief of anxiety and distress, but new fears may arise in anticipating and receiving the planned treatment. Surgery, particularly lumpectomy and axillary dissection, is often performed in an outpatient setting or under short stay procedure. Even the length of hospital stay for mastectomy has been shortened from that of just a few years ago. This means that someone must be available to assist the woman at home, particularly with household tasks or other activities that require arm mobility, and provide some nursing care (e.g. management of surgical drains and dressings). Women undergoing mastectomy and immediate reconstruction, especially with soft tissue flaps from the abdomen, will have a longer hospital stay and a more protracted recovery from surgery. A woman needs to be helped to understand what to expect with each of these procedures, and such preparation is important for her psychological well being and recovery.30

Adjuvant therapy

There is a wide range of adjuvant therapies, from tamoxifen as a single agent, to complex chemotherapy regimens with or without tamoxifen, to newer hormonal therapies. It is advisable for a woman to receive as much information and consultation as necessary before embarking on a course of adjuvant treatment. This helps to ensure that she understands which are the most appropriate for her, given her specific medical, personal, and social situation.3133 The process of gathering information is often stressful, but usually leads to a better understanding and acceptance of the treatment plan.34,35 Most adjuvant chemotherapy is well tolerated, and women often continue many of their usual activities (childcare, household activities, paid employment), albeit often on a reduced schedule, especially modified by treatment administration. The difficulty here is that the receiver of adjuvant treatment is someone who is trying to recover physically and psychologically from a diagnosis of cancer and surgery, and adds additional associated physical symptoms for a period of from four to six months. While it is perceived by most women as a reasonable insurance policy' gainst subsequent breast cancer recurrence, adjuvant treatment significantly decreases quality of life during the treatment course.34,35

After the initial shock of diagnosis and adjustment to treatment, much of the distress is connected to decisions that may impede quality of life and the need to adjust to such physical and emotional changes. Type of surgery, choice of chemotherapy when more than one choice is acceptable, type of radiation therapy (external beam, brachytherapy), and the decision to forgo hormonal suppression are some of the issues that have emotional consequences because they affect anxiety, mood, and stamina.3133

Symptoms

Symptoms, such as hot flashes on tamoxifen treatment, have been reported to decrease general quality of life in women with breast cancer, either directly or through associated disturbed sleep and fatigue.36 Fatigue from treatment, especially in association with pain or other symptoms, can increase anxiety and depression.37 In a cross-sectional study of 841 patients, pain, fatigue, and insomnia were significantly related to loss of physical functioning, even after controlling for cancer treatment and comorbid conditions.38 In a 1-year follow up of the same cohort, chemotherapy was related to reports of fatigue in the short term but not at 1-year post treatment.39

Mental health and overall impact

The processes of care, including feeling like one had a choice of treatment are also important predictors of health outcomes. For example, in one cohort of female patients, choice was independently associated with reports of better mental health.40 Recently, Keating and colleagues extended these results and demonstrated that the concordance between desired and actual decision-making was more important than the actual process itself.41 Receiving chemotherapy (yes vs. no) has not been related to any long-term mental health outcomes except for having a perception that breast cancer had a greater impact on one's life, even after considering stage and other factors.40 One aspect of this negative impact has been distress about the weight gain associated with chemotherapy.42

Social and role function

Social and role functions are inextricably linked to social support and integration prior to breast cancer diagnosis. Breast cancer survivors who are more socially integrated before their diagnosis report better post-treatment role function and vitality than less socially integrated women.43 In fact, Michael and colleagues report that social integration accounts for greater variance in quality of life than treatment itself.43 As a result, others have developed social support interventions targeted to breast cancer survivors with poor support systems. In a recent randomized, prospective trial, the quality of life of older women improved when communicating with a community-based nurse case manager who provided help with managing comorbid conditions, assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs), and help in navigating the health care system.44

Caregiver burden

There is a paucity of data about the impact of breast cancer in older women on their family members and caregivers. Female gender, older age, and past grief experiences have been associated with increased distress and grief in spousal caregivers of cancer patients.45 In one study, daughters and sisters of women with breast cancer perceived that their information and support needs were not well met.46 In another report, Northouse and colleagues found that family members of patients with recurrent disease experienced decrements in emotional well being, and that negative impact was mediated by the ability of the family to deal with the situation and social support.47 Overall, more research is needed to assess caregiver needs and develop appropriate interventions geared to older patients and their families.

Quality of life after the completion of treatment

At the end of primary breast cancer treatment, whether this is at the conclusion of six weeks of radiation therapy or after 4–6 months of adjuvant chemotherapy, most women experience a mixture of elation, fear, and uncertainty.48 Although they have mastered the many aspects of their treatment regimen, they have little preparation and information to guide them in their recovery from treatment. The post-treatment transitional period is a time of considerable psychosocial distress. The paradoxical increase in anxiety has been observed at the end of both radiation and systemic chemotherapy.49 Nevertheless, many women find positive meaning and describe posttraumatic growth from the cancer experience.25 Nevertheless, fear of recurrence is frequently a dominant emotion that is difficult to control, especially before or during follow-up visits.

There has been growing interest in the late effects of breast cancer treatment and the quality of life of long-term survivors beyond the acute phase of treatment. Several published studies have compared breast cancer survivors to healthy, age-matched populations of women and have found few differences in their long-term physical or emotional well being.50,51 A recent study of long-term adjustment of women 20 years after treatment in a large multicenter clinical trial found cancer worries to be negligible; however, 18% of women had posttraumatic stress symptoms, and many reported lymphedema (27%) and numbness (20%) as persistent problems.52 There is some evidence that women who receive adjuvant therapy may have more physical disruption than those who receive no further therapy, and that women who receive chemotherapy may have more sexual dysfunction, and possibly more cognitive dysfunction, than survivors who did not receive similar therapy.5357 With the growing number of breast cancer survivors, as well as increased research funding targeting this population, new evidence will emerge regarding these cognitive and psychosocial concerns.58

Conclusions

The need for psychosocial intervention amongst cancer patients cannot be understated. The goals of planning a psychosocial intervention in the Greek breast cancer context would be to support the patients' ability to cope with the stress of treatment, helping them to tolerate short-term loss for long-term gain, and to assist in symptom management.5961 However, owing to increased patient burden, in-depth psychological intervention to each patient may not be feasible, and some sort of mechanism to cater for to psychosocial problems needs to be identified. Recognizing the subset of women at risk is one such way forward, followed by targeted intervention, such as patient education and counselling.

References

1 

BR Ferrell, M Grant, B FunkQuality of life in breast cancer. Physical and social well-beingCancer Nurs199720398408

2 

CR KingAdvances in how clinical nurses can evaluate and improve quality of life for Individuals with cancerOncol Nurs Forum200633512

3 

SH Perry, TL Kowalski, CH ChangQuality of life assessment in women with breast cancer: benefits, acceptability and utilizationHealth Qual Life Outcomes200752438

4 

P Grimison, MR StocklerQuality of life and adjuvant systemic therapy for early-stage breast cancerExpert Rev Anticancer Ther20077112334

5 

BW Stewart, Kleihues P PaulWorld Cancer ReportLyon, FranceInternational Agency Research on Cancer2003

6 

DK Corle, C Sharbaugh, DJ MateskiSelf-rated quality of life measures: effect of change to a low-fat, high-fiber, fruit and vegetable enriched dietAnn Behav Med200123198207

7 

MH Frost, VJ Suman, TA RummansPhysical, psychological and social wellbeing of women with breast cancer: the influence of disease phasePsychooncology2000922131

8 

HH SchnipperLife after breast cancerJ Clin Oncol20011935814

9 

LC Richardson, W Wang, AG Hartzema, S WagnerThe role of health-related quality of life in early discontinuation of chemotherapy for breast cancerBreast J2007135817

10 

ES Costanzo, SK Lutgendorf, ML MattesAdjusting to life after treatment: distress and quality of life following treatment for breast cancerBr J Cancer200797162531

11 

SE Ward, G Viergutz, D TormeyPatients' reactions to completion of adjuvant breast cancer therapyNurs Res19924136266

12 

DL FertigDepression in patients with breast cancer: prevalence, diagnosis, and treatmentBreast J19973292302

13 

S Tross, JC HollandPsychological sequelae in cancer survivorsJC Holland, JH RowlandHandbook of psychooncology: psychological care of the patient with cancerNew YorkOxford University Press1989101116

14 

A Beisecker, MR Cook, J AshworthSide effects of adjuvant chemotherapy: perceptions of node-negative breast cancer patientsPsychooncology199768593

15 

CE Lethborg, D Kissane, WI Burns, R Snyder“Cast adrift”: the experience of completing treatment among women with early stage breast cancerJ Psychosoc Oncol2000187390

16 

C DeSantis, R Siegel, P Bandi, A JemalBreast Cancer Statistics, 2011CA Cancer J Clin20116140918

17 

MC Terol, S Lopez-Roig, J Rodriguez-MarinDifferences in quality of life: longitudinal study with cancer patients receiving chemotherapy treatmentAn Psicol20001611122

18 

NS Redeker, EL Lev, J RuggieroInsomnia, fatigue, anxiety, depression, and quality of life of cancer patients undergoing chemotherapySch Inq Nurs Pract20001427590

19 

J Engel, J Kerr, A Schlesinger-RaabPredictors of quality of life of breast cancer patientsActa Oncol2003427108

20 

BC Thomas, M Pandey, K Ramdas, MK NairPsychological distress in cancer patients: Hypothesis of a distress modelEur J Cancer Prev20021117985

21 

D Irvine, B Brown, D CrooksPsychosocial adjustment in women with breast cancerCancer1991671097117

22 

MJ Massie, JC HollandPsychological reactions to breast cancer in the pre- and post-surgical periodSemin Surg Oncol199173205

23 

JR Bloom, M Cook, DP FlamerPsychological response to mastectomyCancer19875918996

24 

KT Ashing-Giwa, G Padilla, J TejeroUnderstanding the breast cancer experience of women: a qualitative study of African American, Asian American, Latina and Caucasian cancer survivorsPsychooncology20041340828

25 

PA Ganz, A Coscarelli, C FredBreast cancer survivors: Psychosocial concerns and quality of lifeBreast Cancer Res Treat19963818399

26 

PA Ganz, JH Rowland, K DesmondLife after breast cancer: Understanding women's health-related quality of life and sexual functioningJ Clin Oncol19981650114

27 

PA Ganz, KA Desmond, B LeedhamQuality of life in longterm, disease-free survivors of breast cancer: A follow-up studyJ Natl Cancer Inst2002943949

28 

E Maunsell, J Brisson, L DeschenesPsychological distress after initial treatment of breast cancer. Assessment of potential risk factorsCancer1992701205

29 

CA Schag, PA Ganz, ML PolinskyCharacteristics of women at risk for psychosocial distress in the year after breast cancerJ Clin Oncol19931178393

30 

M WickmanBreast reconstruction: Past achievements, current status, and future goalsScand J Reconstr Hand Surg19952981100

31 

RP McQuellon, HB Muss, SL Hoffman, G RussellPatient preferences for treatment of metastatic breast cancer: A study of women with early-stage breast cancerJ Clin Oncol19951385868

32 

HA Llewellyn-Thomas, HJ Sutherland, DL TritchlerBenign and malignant breast disease: the relationship between women's health status and health valuesMed Decis Making1991111808

33 

BJ McNeil, SG Pauker Jr, HC Sox, A TverskyOn the elicitation of preferences for alternative therapiesN Engl J Med1987306125962

34 

JE Till, HJ Sutherland, EM MeslinIs there a role for preference assessments in research on quality of life in oncology?Qual Life Res199213140

35 

SB Yellen, DF CellaSomeone to live for: Social well-being, parenthood status, and decision-making in oncologyJ Clin Oncol199513125564

36 

KD Stein, PB Jacobsen, DM HannImpact of hot flashes on quality of life among postmenopausal women being treated for breast cancerJ Pain Symptom Manage20001943645

37 

P Stone, M Richards, R A'Hern, J HardyA study to investigate the prevalence, severity and correlates of fatigue among patients with cancer in comparison with a control group of volunteers without cancerAnn Oncol2000115617

38 

B Given, C Given, F Azzouz, M StommelPhysical functioning of elderly cancer patients prior to diagnosis and following initial treatmentNurs Res20015022232

39 

CW Given, B Given, F AzzouzPredictors of pain and fatigue in the year following diagnosis among elderly cancer patientsJ Pain Symptom Manage20012145666

40 

J Mandelblatt, SB Edge, NJ MeropolPredictors of long-term outcomes in older breast cancer survivors: perceptions versus patterns of careJ Clin Oncol20032185563

41 

N Keating, E Guadagnoli, M LandrumPatients participation in treatment decision making: Should Physicians match patients desired levels of involvement?J Clin Oncol20022014739

42 

JA McInnes, MT KnobfWeight gain and quality of life in women treated with adjuvant chemotherapy for early-stage breast cancerOncol Nurs Forum20012867584

43 

YL Michael, LF Berkman, GA ColditzSocial networks and health-related quality of life in breast cancer survivors: a prospective studyJ Psychosom Res20025228593

44 

A Jennings-Sanders, ET AndersonOlder women with breast cancer perceptions of the effectiveness of nurse case managersNursing Outlook20035110814

45 

O Gilbar, H Ben-ZurBereavement of spouse caregivers of cancer patientsAm J Orthopsychiatry20027242232

46 

K Chalmers, S Marles, D TatarynReports of information and support needs of daughters and sisters of women with breast cancerEur J Cancer Care2003128190

47 

LL Northouse, D Mood, T KershawQuality of life of women with recurrent breast cancer and their family membersJ Clin Oncol200220405064

48 

JH Rowland, MJ MassieBreast Cancer in Psycho-OncologyJ HollandNew YorkOxford University Press1989

49 

JC Holland, JH RowlandPsychological reactions to breast cancer and its treatmentJR Harris, S Hellman, IC Henderson, DW KinneBreast DiseasesPhiladelphiaLippincott1991849866

50 

BL Andersen, B Anderson, C de ProsseControlled prospective longitudinal study of women with cancer. II. Psychological outcomesJ Consult Clin Psychol1989576927

51 

M Dorval, E Maunsell, L Deschenes, J BrissonType of mastectomy and quality of life for long term breast carcinoma survivorsCancer19988321308

52 

AB Kornblith, C Zhang, JE Herndon IILong-term adjustment of survivors of early stage breast cancer 20 years after adjuvant chemotherapyCancer20039867989

53 

TA Ahles, AJ Saykin, CT FurstenbergNeuropsychologic impact of standard-dose systemic chemotherapy in long-term survivors of breast cancer and lymphomaJ Clin Oncol20022048593

54 

CB Brezden, KA Phillips, M AbdolellCognitive function in breast cancer patients receiving adjuvant chemotherapyJ Clin Oncol2000182695701

55 

BE Meyerowitz, KA Desmond, JH RowlandSexuality following breast cancerJ Sex Marital Ther19992523750

56 

SB Schagen, FS van Dam, MJ MullerCognitive deficits after postoperative adjuvant chemotherapy for breast carcinomaCancer19998564050

57 

FS van Dam, SB Schagen, MJ MullerImpairment of cognitive function in women receiving adjuvant treatment for high-risk breast cancer: High-dose versus standard-dose chemotherapyJ Natl Cancer Inst1998902108

58 

CC Gotay, MY MuraokaQuality of life in long-term survivors of adult-onset cancersJ Natl Cancer Inst19989065667

59 

PB Jacobsen, DH Bovbjerg, MD SchwartzConditioned emotional distress in women receiving chemotherapy for breast cancerJ Consult Clin Psychol19956310814

60 

SL Shapiro, AM Lopez, GE SchwartzQuality of life and breast cancer: relationship to psychosocial variablesJ Clin Psychol20015750119

61 

DK Payne, MD Sullivan, MJ MassieWomen's psychological reactions to breast cancerSemin Oncol1996238997

Abstract views:
2821

Views:
PDF
792
HTML
377

Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM


Copyright (c) 2012 Theofilou Paraskevi

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
 
© PAGEPress 2008-2018     -     PAGEPress is a registered trademark property of PAGEPress srl, Italy.     -     VAT: IT02125780185